Hands up, those who can rewind quickly and still vividly remember the happenings of Friday 29th August 2014! It is now common knowledge that on that fateful day, the then Commander of the Lesotho Defence Force, Lieutenant-General Tlali Kamoli was removed from his position as Commander by His Majesty King Letsie III, on the advice of the Prime Minister, Dr Tom Thabane and replaced by Lieutenant-General Maaparankoe Mahao. The fact that the dismissed Commander refused to leave office is not relevant to the matter below because the legal instruments were issued for his dismissal.
It is also a matter of common public knowledge that the Prime Minister Mosisili who succeeded Dr Thabane following the February 2015 general election, re-instated Lieutenant-General Kamoli in the most baffling and bemusing manner ever. Dr Mosisili dismissed Lieutenant-General Mahao retrospectively from the date that he was appointed by his predecessor, and in the same move, re-appointed Lieutenant-General Kamoli retrospectively from the date that he was dismissed in 2014.
I have, for all this while, been thoroughly dismayed that the Lesotho Law Society and the Law Faculty of the National University of Lesotho have both not gone into overdrive to analyse and dissect this legal conundrum. I am not learned by any measure, however, I would like to venture an opinion that in a purest and simplistic sense, the action of Prime Minister Mosisili sought to “expunge” (remember that word) Mahao’s appointment and tenure as Commander and pretend that it did not happen at all. It is as if time stood still. However, because we live in the real world where time does not stand still for anyone, and assuming that both the appointment of Mahao and re-appointment of Kamoli were lawful and legitimate; the practical, legal consequence of Prime Minister Mosisili’s action is that it renders Lesotho as having had two bona fide Commanders of the Lesotho Defence Force during the period from 29th August 2014 to 22nd May 2015 when Mahao was eventually dismissed. Is having two concurrent Commanders of the Lesotho Defence Force consistent with the Lesotho Constitution?
Fast forward to a hypothetical situation in 2016. Dr Thabane returns as Prime Minister through a legitimate process (elections, parliamentary shifts/floor crossing/vote of no confidence etc.). He then re-appoints Mr. Khothatso Tsooana (apologies to Mr. Tsooana, the use of his name here is purely illustrative and not indicative) as Police Commissioner retrospectively from the date when he was dismissed by former Prime Minister Mosisili. Imagine that!! Now, who in the world would cry foul and challenge that? It would also mean that Lesotho would have had two concurrent Police Commissioners during some period, but hey, this is Lesotho. But wait, it gets even better.
If Prime Minister W today, dismisses Minister X from the Cabinet, and replaces him/her with Minister Y, can Prime Minister Z tomorrow, appoint Minister X to his Cabinet, and appoint him/her retrospectively from the date when he/she was dismissed from the Cabinet of Prime Minister W, and in so doing, enforce the status of Minister X as having still been a Minister from the date that he/she was dismissed by Prime Minister W up to the time when his/her tenure as Minister would have ended anyway, perhaps through dissolution of Parliament and a general election?
The central question here is whether a sitting Prime Minister can “stray” into the term of a former Prime Minister and undo appointments of incumbents occupying statutory positions, where such appointments have been made lawfully and legitimately. This precedent now set by Prime Minister Mosisili needs to be interrogated, analysed and ruled upon by the Courts of Law, because if left unchecked, as is currently the case, some smart politician in future will ruffle feathers and precipitate a crisis. Professor Nqosa Mahao touched upon this very issue during the press conference convened by the Mahao Family on the afternoon of 27th June 2016, where he stated that the “unadulterated” version of the Phumaphi Report stated that the dismissal of Lt General Mahao and re-appointment of Lt. General Kamoli, in the way that it was done was illegal as opposed to the other published version which cites this as having been irregular.
Now, the treatise above, tries to examine the legality of the re-appointment of Lt. General Kamoli, through the eyes of a lay legal mind, by posing scenarios and questions that the learned community should pursue with vigour, through answering the central question posed above. What is still to be dealt with is the other side of the legality coin in respect of the re-appointment of Lt. General Kamoli, namely; is the re-appointment of a Commander who was de-commissioned by his Majesty King Letsie III consistent with the Lesotho Defence Force Act, as well as accepted international military conventions and protocols. I suppose that Prime Minister Mosisili was trying to “expunge” (that word again) the de-commissioned officer argument by making the re-appointment retrospective. But in so doing, Prime Minister Mosisili appears to have plunged himself into a legal abyss from which he may possibly be unable to escape; because wish as he may, time did not stand still from 29th August 2014 to 22nd May 2015. All Prime Ministers are equal, no Prime Minister is more equal than others.
Hands up again, those who remember the Court of Appeal case Attorney General v His Majesty the King and Others, whose judgement was handed down on 12th June 2015. You will all recall how the Attorney General lodged this case which he had earlier lost in the High Court, on the basis that the appointment of the President of the Court of Appeal was unlawful. Again, I am not learned, but I would like to venture an opinion that lodging a case against the re-appointment of Lt. General Kamoli on the rudimentary arguments advanced herein would be easy pickings for the Attorney General. The more pertinent question, however, is whether the Attorney General is of the considered view that the re-appointment is legal and proper. Why is the Attorney General, someone who is entrusted with defending the constitution, not concerned? If a Court of Law were to rule that the re-appointment was illegal, what would that mean for the alleged negotiations for an exit package for Lt. General Kamoli? Are we not giving a golden handshake to someone whose occupancy of the position of Commander may be illegal?
Lesotho needs answers to these burning questions, Lesotho needs to reform her Constitution to free herself from the shackles of the past 2 years, but it is important to defend the Constitution from those who subvert it.
Guest Author of lesothoanalysis.wordpress.com
July 5, 2016 at 4:54 pm
Guess it’s time PM packs his bags & vamoose
July 5, 2016 at 4:58 pm
He’s definitely incompetent,& so are his sidekicks.
July 6, 2016 at 7:42 am
Interesting piece Lesothoanalysis, Guest Author. But this is Lesotho remember!!! Once you are in power, you replace the doctrine of rule of law with RULE BY LAW where now law becomes an instrument used to against political enemies; national laws and constitution do not matter any more. What matters is to be in power at all costs, including committing cross-human rights violations: cold-blooded murders by self-declared state agents; incarceration and systematic torture of perceived enemies; denying them food and chronic medication when they are helpless; putting them in solidarity confinement because their children of all ages, including two-year-olds, are BEGGING for their freedom; and intimidation of all sorts to those who believe in democratic rule in which human life is sacred.
International instruments to which you voluntarily committed no longer matter; decisions by international bodies on issues you have invited them to work on are not binding; sovereignty becomes a shield to protect you against accountability for your own actions and those of your protectors. This is the Lesotho of our times! But there is a glimmer of hope that WE WILL BE FORCED TO BE FREE again. International community from all quarters is reminding us to preserve for Basotho those universal human values of security from physical harm and freedom. There is an end insight. Those who have to account will, no matter when. We hope it will happen in our lifetime!
July 6, 2016 at 11:58 am
Prime Minister Mosisili’s spurious justifications for re-appointing Lt Gen Tlali Kamoli, namely to correct an injustice–Kamoli had not been properly dismissed, Kamoli had not been given a hearing, Mahao was facing a court martial–have all been found to be false. It must follow logic then that the Prime Minister erred in his re-appointment and that such appointment cannot stand both in law and common sense. As the commander’s infractions were already obvious, there must be another powerful but less sensible reason that drove the Prime Minister to make this appointment. In time that reason will emerge.
That the law society has so far elected not to challenge this brazen violation of common principles of governance and law is symptomatic of its acquiescence to the systematic capture of democratic institutions that speak truth to power and provide a check against abuse of power.
There is no plausible situation under which Basotho must pay through their taxes to buy off a person whose appointment is legally and common-sensically unsound. The only remaining explanation is that Prime Minister Mosisili is committing all Basotho to pay ransom to a hostage taker. Are we now forced to buy our freedom?
The irregular re-appointment with spurious reasons, the now muted ransom, and the inexplicable extolling of the virtues of the commander by the PM and his ministers point to something else that time will bare.